House Committee Approves Bill Preventing Federal Courts to Rule on Pledge

By Katherine T. Phan

Although in June, the U.S. Supreme Court dismissed a case challenging the “under God” phrase in the Pledge of Allegiance, it will no longer have jurisdiction to declare the phrase unconstitutional if a legislation approved by a House committee yesterday passes in the full House.

The House of Representatives Judiciary Committee voted, 17-10, in favor of a bill that would ban all federal courts, including the U.S. Supreme Court, from hearing or deciding cases "pertaining to the interpretation of, or the validity under the Constitution of, the Pledge of Allegiance … or its recitation."

The full House will begin debate on the measure next week on top of considering a federal constitutional amendment banning same-sex “marriage.”

Under the bill, H.R. 2028., sponsored by Representative Todd Akin (R-Mo.) alongside 224 co-sponsors, only state jurists will be able to decide on challenges to the Pledge.

Committee Chairman James Sensenbrenner (R-Wi.) said the amended legislation would “place final authority over a state’s pledge policy in the hands of the states themselves.”

Akin introduced the bill "[i]n order to protect the pledge from federal court decisions that would have the effect of invalidating the pledge across several states," said Sensenbrenner.

Democrats from the Judiciary committee say the bill violates the constitutional balance of powers between the judicial and legislative branches.

Republicans, which comprise the majority of the committee, disagree, citing Article III, Section II of the constitution, which gives Congress the authority to except many areas of federal law from judicial review.

"A remedy to abuses by federal judges has long been understood to lie, among other places, in Congress' authority to limit federal court jurisdiction," Sensenbrenner said.

Last month, the House passed H.R. 3313, which prevents federal courts from deciding on cases involving the Defense of Marriage Act, a law that exempts states from recognizing same-sex marriages performed in other states.

"Far from violating the separation of powers, legislation that leaves state courts with jurisdiction to decide certain classes of cases would be an exercise of one of the very 'checks and balances' provided for in the Constitution,” said Sensenbrenner.

"State courts are not second-class courts, and they are perfectly competent to decide federal constitutional cases,” he said.

Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah), chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, has told Akin, that he supports the bill and would push a Senate version if the House acted.

  • [Exclusive Interview] A revelation within the brink of life and death — Meg Leung’s mission in Christian art

    Meg Leung (梁麗橋), an artist with a lifelong love for watercolor painting, sees her art as more than a means of expressing her inner world; it is a bridge connecting her to God. Her artistic journey has revealed God’s perfect plan and inspired her to communicate the power of faith through her wor

  • Transgenderism a fundamental human right? Hong Kong public disagrees, survey finds

    A 2024 survey from the Society for Truth and Light (明光社)'s Center for Life and Ethics Research reveals that respondents from various backgrounds prioritize personal safety and fairness when it comes to transgender issues. When laws involve moral judgments, most respondents believe courts should not make the decisions. The study also indicates that religious believers share similar views with non-religious respondents, reflecting that many churches may rarely address gender topics in depth.

  • Discipleship and Evangelism: Walking the Path of the Great Commission

    Like an ever-flowing spring, the gospel refreshes dry, parched lands and needs our unwavering passion and steadfast faith to transform lives and bring renewal. The "flame in our hearts" calls Christians to keep their faith and love for the Lord ablaze, representing the work and power of the Holy Spirit, driving us to proclaim God's glory boldly.

  • North America Chinese Evangelical Seminary year-end report highlights significant ministry progress

    As the year draws to a close, Rev. James Liu, President of the Chinese Evangelical Seminary North America (CESNA), reflected on the seminary’s remarkable growth and ministry development over the past year. Dedicated to providing theological education to Chinese Christians, CESNA continues to uphold its mission to remain faithful to the gospel and nurture believers. This year’s achievements span academic, ministerial, and outreach endeavors, fostering spiritual growth and advancing missionary wo