Faith-based films often receive mixed reactions, and The Last Supper is no exception. The movie attempts to bring a fresh perspective to one of the most iconic moments in Christian history, but does it succeed? Some reviews from critics and audiences provide insight into its strengths and shortcomings.
The Last Supper is a 2025 faith-based film directed by Mauro Borrelli. The movie portrays the events leading up to Jesus’ final meal with His disciples, focusing on the emotional and spiritual weight of that historic moment. Starring James Oliver Wheatley as Peter, Jamie Ward as Jesus, and a supporting cast that brings the biblical narrative to life, the film aims to provide an intimate retelling of the Last Supper. Christian artist Chris Tomlin served as the executive producer. It was released on March 14, 2025, and has since generated a range of reactions from critics and audiences alike.
According to Religion Unplugged offers a more critical perspective, arguing that while the filmmakers had a clear passion for the project, the film itself falls short in execution. According to the review, faith-based cinema has evolved, and audiences should expect higher quality from Christian films. The review points out that The Last Supper competes with other major Jesus-centered content, such as The Chosen, yet fails to distinguish itself. While the film presents an intriguing focus on the contrasting journeys of Peter and Judas, the execution is hindered by weak performances and lackluster storytelling. The dialogue is described as overly simplistic, and the cinematography and editing fail to add depth to the narrative. Despite some strong moments, particularly in portraying Judas' spiritual struggle, the review ultimately suggests that Christian audiences should demand both strong storytelling and theological depth in faith-based films.
Meanwhile, The Catholic Standard provides a mixed but generally positive review, praising the film’s reverent tone and strong visual storytelling. According to the publication, director Mauro Borrelli, known for his work as an art designer, brings a striking visual depth to The Last Supper. Jamie Ward’s portrayal of Jesus is noted for its serene and composed presence, while James Oliver Wheatley as Peter effectively conveys remorse and inner conflict. However, Robert Knepper’s portrayal of Judas is seen as overly dramatic, partly due to how the script presents his motivations. The review highlights the film’s emotional depth in moments closely following Scripture, such as the foot-washing scene, but critiques its attempts to expand the biblical narrative, which sometimes feel forced. Additionally, the film’s depiction of intense violence, including Jesus’ suffering and crucifixion, makes it unsuitable for younger audiences.
Movieguide offers a detailed review, highlighting The Last Supper as a visually striking retelling of the Gospel story, focusing on Jesus’ suffering, crucifixion, and resurrection. The review praises the film’s strong biblical themes and its effort to depict the most important love story ever told—God’s sacrifice for humanity. The depiction of Jesus’ journey to Jerusalem, His cleansing of the Temple, and the Last Supper itself is noted for staying true to Scripture while incorporating some creative license, particularly in its portrayal of Jewish traditions and Satan’s influence over Judas.
So, is The Last Supper worth watching? If you’re looking for a film that faithfully portrays biblical events and offers a reflective viewing experience, it might be a meaningful choice. However, for those seeking a more dynamic and dramatically compelling narrative, the film may fall short. Ultimately, its value depends on the viewer’s expectations and willingness to embrace its faith-centered approach.
