N.Y. Judge: Same-sex marriage is not a fundamental right

A New York state judge rejects challenges to New York's Domestic Relations Law which only recognizes marriages between heterosexual couples.

A New York state judge Justice has ruled Thursday that Orangetown Town Clerk Charlotte Madigan acted correctly when she denied marriage licenses to 10 same-sex couples, which included Nyack Mayor John Shields and his partner.

The couples had filed suit to seeking to force Madigan to issue the licenses and to force the Health Department to recognize the licenses.

Shields said the judge made “a political decision rather than a decision for the civil rights of all people.” Weiner is one of the 13 candidates running for a 9th Judicial District state Supreme Court justice seat.

Justice Alfred Weiner upheld state Domestic Relations Law and ruled marriage licenses were only issued to heterosexual couples. He rejected arguments made by same-sex couples that the city and state violated their civil rights by denying the licenses. He said homosexuals have rights to marry, just not people of the same sex.

"Same-sex marriage is not a fundamental right protected by the due-process clause of the New York state Constitution," Weiner said in his ruling made available Friday. "The institution of marriage is a fundamental right founded on the distinction of sex and the potential for procreation. Homosexual marriages do not fall within those guideposts or serve such ends."

Weiner also stated that fundamental rights were those "deeply rooted in this nation's history and tradition” in response to plaintiffs’ claims that tradition did not constitute enough reason to keep the ban on same-sex marriage.

"For that reason," Weiner wrote, "the courts are necessarily reluctant to expand the scope and definition of fundamental rights. Exercising such restraint here, this court declines petitioners' request to include in those rights, considered fundamental to our concept of ordered liberty, the right to marry a person of the same sex."

The future of same-sex marriage should be determined by the state Legislature and not by the courts, the judge concluded.

Lambda Legal agreed in a statement issued on Oct. 22. "No doubt this question -- whether same-sex couples have an equal right to marry under the state's Constitution -- will be answered by the state's high court," the statement read.

In New York State, the Domestic Relations Law governs the marriage laws. The state does not have a Defense of Marriage Act.

Eleven states will vote on constitutional amendments banning same-sex marriage on Nov. 2.

    Most Popular
  • Is 'The Last Supper' worth watching? Audience and critics weigh in

    Is 'The Last Supper' worth watching? Audience and critics weigh in

    Faith-based films often receive mixed reactions, and The Last Supper is no exception. The movie attempts to bring a fresh perspective to one of the most iconic moments in Christian history, but does it succeed? Some reviews from critics and audiences provide insight into its strengths and shortcomings.

  • ‘The Chosen’ Season 5: The darkest season yet—What to know before watching

    The wait is over—The Chosen is back with its fifth season, and this time, things are getting intense. The new episodes dive straight into the final days of Jesus’ life, covering some of the most emotional and dramatic moments in the Bible. If you’ve been following the series, you already know that The Chosen isn’t just about retelling familiar stories—it’s about bringing them to life in a way that feels real.

  • Massacres in Syria: Over 1,000 dead, including Christians and Alawites

    Syria’s coastal regions have been devastated by a series of massacres, with reports indicating that over 1,000 people—many from Christian and Alawite communities—have been killed in brutal attacks. Entire families have been wiped out, and survivors are fleeing in search of safety as sectarian violence escalates.

  • Kim Sae-ron and Wheesung: The tragic irony of Korean society and the principles of happiness

    Not long ago, the media was in an uproar over actress Kim Sae-ron’s passing. Just months before, the same people who had relentlessly criticized her for her DUI incident were now expressing sympathy, saying, "The world was too harsh on her." The irony is impossible to ignore.

  • Newsboys move forward as a quartet after Michael Tait’s departure

    After more than a decade as the lead singer of the Newsboys, Michael Tait has officially parted ways with the band, marking a significant shift in the Christian rock group’s lineup. The remaining members—Jeff Frankenstein, Jody Davis, Duncan Phillips, and Adam Agee—have assured fans that they will continue forward, embracing a new season of music and ministry.