Transgender Students Sue School District for Making Them Use Restrooms Based on Their Biological Sex

By Suzette Gutierrez-Cachila
All Gender Bathroom
Photo -- A sign is seen in the bathroom stalls at the 21C Museum Hotel in Durham, North Carolina in this May 3, 2016 file photo.  Reuters/Jonathan Drake

Three transgender students filed a lawsuit against a school district in Pennsylvania for requiring students to use restrooms according to their biological sex.

The three plaintiffs said Pine-Richland School District discriminated against them when it imposed a board resolution last month that did not allow transgender students from using restrooms corresponding to their gender identity.

Before this resolution was implemented, they were free to use restrooms based on the gender they identify with, the three students said.

The past weeks had been difficult, according to 18-year-old Juliet Evancho, one of the plaintiffs.

“These past three weeks have felt like three years because we felt so trapped and so discriminated against,” Evancho said“Before this all started, Pine-Richland was a very safe, kind extremely comforting place. Everyone was so sweet.”

Evancho was born male but now identifies as a female. Evancho’s legal first name, formerly Jacob, has been changed to Juliet.

The other two plaintiffs were 18-year-old Erik Ridenour, also born male but now identifies as female and wants to be addressed as “Elissa,” and a 17-year-old student known only by the initials A.S., who was born female and now identifies as male.

Omar Gonzalez-Pagan, attorney at Lambda Legal who filed the lawsuit on behalf of the three students, said the school board resolution is a “discriminatory policy” that “erases” the transgender students’ identity.

“Forcing transgender students to use the restrooms that do not match their gender identity or forcing them to use separate single-stall restrooms erases transgender students’ gender identity, endangers their health and safety, and isolates them from the rest of the student body,” Gonzales-Pagan wrote regarding the case.

He argued that the new policy regarding the use of bathrooms is “unconstitutional” because it discriminates against students on the basis of sex and gender identity. He added that transgender students should not be treated like “second-class” students.

"The reality is Juliet is a girl, Elissa is a girl and A.S. is a boy," Gonzalez-Pagan said.

Peter Lyons, school board director, said the new policy does not represent the school district’s “respect and support” for the students.

“It is unfortunate that five members of our board chose to change a practice of the district that had been in place without controversy for some years,” Lyons said in a statement. “This change was not representative of the respect and support the Pine-Richland community extends to all of our students, regardless of their gender identity or sexual orientation.”

He clarified, however, that the statement he issued was his own alone and not that of the entire board.

Pine-Richland School District has yet to issue a statement.

  • [Exclusive Interview] A revelation within the brink of life and death — Meg Leung’s mission in Christian art

    Meg Leung (梁麗橋), an artist with a lifelong love for watercolor painting, sees her art as more than a means of expressing her inner world; it is a bridge connecting her to God. Her artistic journey has revealed God’s perfect plan and inspired her to communicate the power of faith through her wor

  • Transgenderism a fundamental human right? Hong Kong public disagrees, survey finds

    A 2024 survey from the Society for Truth and Light (明光社)'s Center for Life and Ethics Research reveals that respondents from various backgrounds prioritize personal safety and fairness when it comes to transgender issues. When laws involve moral judgments, most respondents believe courts should not make the decisions. The study also indicates that religious believers share similar views with non-religious respondents, reflecting that many churches may rarely address gender topics in depth.

  • Discipleship and Evangelism: Walking the Path of the Great Commission

    Like an ever-flowing spring, the gospel refreshes dry, parched lands and needs our unwavering passion and steadfast faith to transform lives and bring renewal. The "flame in our hearts" calls Christians to keep their faith and love for the Lord ablaze, representing the work and power of the Holy Spirit, driving us to proclaim God's glory boldly.

  • North America Chinese Evangelical Seminary year-end report highlights significant ministry progress

    As the year draws to a close, Rev. James Liu, President of the Chinese Evangelical Seminary North America (CESNA), reflected on the seminary’s remarkable growth and ministry development over the past year. Dedicated to providing theological education to Chinese Christians, CESNA continues to uphold its mission to remain faithful to the gospel and nurture believers. This year’s achievements span academic, ministerial, and outreach endeavors, fostering spiritual growth and advancing missionary wo